December 28, 2009

Early Derby Choices and a Very Special Announcement

I know it's early, but Friday we will only be four months away from the First Saturday in May, the Greatest Two Minutes in Sports, the Run for the Roses: The Kentucky Derby! So with that I'm going to put out my first Derby prospects together in this post. I will tell you that the horse that I'm gaga over (aka Rule) is not #1 (I'm not that stupid to put a G3 winner ahead of a G1 winner on the first list), nor is the Juvenile Champ (Vale of York (IRE)). However, I think the rest of the list is very reasonble and interesting. There are five of them for right now going in reverse order (worst to best, although all of these horses are very good horses).

#5 Noble's Promise (Cuvee): Won the Dixiana Breeders Futurity (G1) and the Fitz Dixon, Jr. Memorial Juvenile Stakes. He was third in the BC Juvenile (behind Vale of York and Lookin at Lucky), and second in the Cash Call Futurity. The big concern with him is that he's never been on dirt (only synth and turf) and his sire Cuvee had one race beyond a mile and he finished last. Now of course Noble has out done his father by winning the mile and sixtheenth Breeders, but still the question of dirt is big.

#4 Blind Luck (Pollard's Vision): Is Calder the new Mid Alantic? Up until Old Fashioned's injury and Friesan Fire's debacle this year, since 2004 the Mid Alantic has sent horses who have gone on to star status starting with Smarty Jones, going to Afleet Alex, then Barbaro, then Hard Spun and finally Eight Belles and Proud Spell. Calder may just take the title away from them, with stakes winner Jackson Bend, G1 winner Homeboykris and G2 winner D'Funnybone all starting their careers at the Florida racetrack. However, the best of them all could be this filly. Filly? Uhh you know there is a race for them, don't you? Yes I know the likelyhood of this girl ending up in the Derby isn't great, but right now she is my Oaks pick and the early favorite for the race. Her only two losses where in the Del Mar Debutante and BC Juvenile Fillies, her Hollywood Starlet was by far the most impressive race I saw this year by a two year old. The cool thing is she has a win over a dirt surface. Now granted it was over 40k claimers, but still a dirt win is a plus. Hopefully she does well next year weather she is Derby or Oaks bound.

#3 Super Saver (Maria's Mon): Lets see WinStar bred, from the same female family as the sire of Personal Ensign, by a 2yo champion who has sired a Derby champ, and oh yeah did I mention he's a WinStar homebred? From the same people who brought you horses such as Funny Cide (although he did not run for WinStar), Bluegrass Cat and Colonel John brings you this G2 winner. The WinStar boys are loaded this year with a potential three headed monster (Super Saver, American Lion, and Rule). He has a win on dirt and a win at Churchill. That helped Rachel Alexandra this year, and I think it will help Super Saver next year.

#2 Buddy's Saint (Saint Liam): How hard was it to leave Rule off this list? It was extreamly hard that if he had been here, in all likely this guy (or Blind Luck) would have been left off. However, the fact that he has crossed the line first in all three of his races (he was DQ'ed from his maiden win, but rebroke his maiden in the Nashua), and that he will be facing horses such as Winslow Homer, Super Saver and Rule puts him #2. This is Saint Liam's only crop after a freak accident claimed his life, hopefully Buddy can make his dad very proud. The New York 2yo route has been hit or miss, but the fact that he has a win over dirt is a plus.

#1 Lookin at Lucky (Smart Strike): Cross out the BC Juvy, that was IMO a fluke win for Vale of York. Lucky was able to return to the winners circle in the Cash Call Futurity. Of course the concern of him not winning on dirt is a strike. However, Bob Baffert (who is loaded himself of Derby prospects) has said that he will prep on dirt before the Derby. This is HUGE news considering he will have to leave Cali in order to get a dirt surface. I don't think him ajusting to a dirt surface will be a big problem, however like synths not all dirt surfaces will be alike. Baffert has three Derby winners, (Silver Charm, Real Quiet and War Emblem) is this the year he gets his fourth? Only time will tell.

Honorble Mention: Rule (Roman Ruler), Winslow Homer (Unbridled's Song), Aikenite (Yes It's True), American Lion (Tiznow)

I need to see more from: Jackson Bend (Hear No Evil)

I plan on doing a Top 5 list at the end of each month leading up to the Derby. If this is successful, I may bring it back after a 2 month break in May and June for the Breeders' Cup. Until then I hope that you enjoy this list.

Meanwhile I announced on the Facebook Fan page (you need to be a member of Facebook in order to see most of the activities), that I had a very special announcement to make. If you did not read my Twitter page earlier tonight, then you don't know about my very exciting news. I got accepected into the Thoroughbred Bloggers Alliance (TBA as it's known by). From their website, the TBA "are a diverse group of horse racing professionals and fans blogging about the sport we love." You can find the TBA website at: http://tbablogs.com/

I'm honored to be part of this group and in celebration of me getting in, I'm asking all my readers to donate (if they can) to Old Friends (TBA's choice) or a horse rescue of your choice. This is really exciting and I really want to thank Patrick and Brian of TBA for accepting Thoroughbred Chat as a member. Thanks guys!

6 comments:

  1. I totally agree about the BC Juvy being a fluke. Vale of York is not a real Derby contender, and Lookin at Lucky is, although I think he is peaking now and is vulnerable. I, like you, am a huge fan of Rule and think he should be on the list instead of Blind Luck. Blind Luck is fantastic, but she likely won't run in the Derby. Rule is pursuing the perfect path to the Derby, he is a pure dirt runner, and his pedigree fits.
    Congrats on the TBA membership, you certainly deserve it, a very insightful blogger.
    - Trifectabox

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yeah I really wanted to put him there, but I couldn't say no to Blind Luck or Buddy's Saint. With that being said of the three of them, I think Rule will be in the gate when it comes to the Derby and BL in the Oaks. Buddy it's really up in the air, as he's Liam's only chance (unless another Liam comes around and suprises everyone) to get into the Derby. And thank you, I'm really excited about being accepted.

    ReplyDelete
  3. With the exception of Blind Luck - it was a fairly obvious and bland list for 2010 Derby prospects. To say you wouldn't put a G3 winner infront of a G1 winner is silly since many two year old G1 winners don't train on to be special at three. I on the other hand , took a stand.

    I don't feel Lookin at Lucky will be able to win at 10 furlongs on May 1st. Just because he is the best juvinelle doesn't make him the best Derby prospect.

    I have listed Afleet Express as my number one Derby prospect- 99% of players will have no idea who this colt is - but they will.

    Check out my list - I have 14 colts listed currently and may update to List #2 today.

    ReplyDelete
  4. So you are putting a horse who has made 1 start, broke awarkwardly and hasn't run farther then six furlongs? Okie dokie, like I said before this is an early list things will change. I looked at your list, I feel that Dublin is quite overrated. If he where good then he would have been able to beat Homeboykris and Thisskyhasnolimit. Also Super Saver comes from a Phipps family, but he's a WinStar homebred.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for the correction on Super Saver - he has much more panache because of his Phipps family not because Winstar bred him.

    Yes - Afleet Express is #1 on my list. I saw in his stride exactly the same thing I saw in Fu-Pegs stride when he broke his maiden in December of 1999. Watch the re-play. All I look for is 'the stride'.

    You have to have imagination to put together a Derby list. Take a chance. If you like Rule put him down. To make a list of just well known two year olds makes me think you also play favorites or just don't watch alot of races. The point is to predict the horses as you think they will rank on May 1st. Many wise guys like me don't think Lookin at Lucky even has a chance at the Derby. He'll never get the distance.

    Dublin might be overrated but to say "if he were good, he would have beaten Homeboykris and Thesskyhasnolimit is just ridiculous. 99% of horses lose a race. They are living breathing animals who sometimes don't want to run. Dublins maiden victory came in one of the strongest maiden races I have ever seen at Saratoga. I was so impressed with the race , I had Eightyfiveinafifty listed because he flew home for 3rd in the same race. I have been going to Saratoga for 30 years and hardly miss a race. His potential is astounding. I just hope Mr Lucas can get the best from him.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Well you have your opinon and I have mine. I'm allowed to say what I want and the same goes for you. We can just agree to disagree.

    ReplyDelete